
Originally Posted by
btdog
Troubleshooting is a pain. Troubleshooting an 8 year-old system is an even greater pain. After about 5 years, most components are susceptible to failure, which means any part could be the culprit, or worse yet, two or more components have failed.
Still, here are my thoughts:
I agree with you, the PSU is typically the most common part to fail and cause symptoms like you're seeing. I don't know why the technician wouldn't swap out PSUs, even if it was for giggles. To test your theory, you'll have to get your hands on a known good PSU. Good news, you can usually find a good quality PSU (Corsair comes to mind) for about $60-70.
After the PSU, in order, I would suspect the mobo, then RAM, then GPU.
I would also remove one of the GPUs. You should remove any non-essential parts to narrow the focus and help with identification of the failed part. CPU, mobo, PSU, RAM, GPU, keyboard, mouse and C: drive are all you need.
You say you're not tech savvy but perhaps a friend of yours who is would be willing to help.
Hope this helps.